46 comments

• 

  Michael Masnick

  2 years ago

  This particular story keeps popping up every so often... and it's always the exact same characters on both sides. You don't name the two people, but I'm sure I can guess who they are from previous articles on the topic.
  
  However, as I wrote when just such an article popped up a month ago, if the market is already incredibly innovative and competitive, why should we put up new barriers? The market seems to work as is, encouraging designers to keep innovating and keep coming out with something new. So it's hard to see what the societal benefit of increased protection is.
• 

  Noel Le

  2 years ago

  I agree with Mike.
  
  I would caution that the difficulty or complexity of applying legal standards is different from lack of "bright lines." Note that many legal disputes in IP are decided by balancing/weighing elements or prongs (the fair use and abstraction tests in copyright are good examples). To replace these tests with "bright lines" sounds like a proposition for deciding IP disputes purely by prima facie observations, or worse, advocacy for replacing our common law system for the civil code.
• 

  Erik

  2 years ago

  There's an interesting discussion of the issue over at AntitrustProf Blog.

  
  

  If you buy the notion that it's a good idea to protect boat hull designs, then why not extend protection to fashion? On the other hand, if we protect boat hull designs and dresses, why not patent storylines and plots, or extend copyright to protect a hairdo. Maybe Tyra Banks can gain IP protection for her figure (not just her persona, but her figure). In order to protect himself against infringement, Walter Payton should be able to secure the rights on his running moves, so no NFL rookies will be able to steal from him.

  
  

  Getting back to reality, protection of industrial designs is not new. The Copyright Office prepared an interesting report about proposed protections for fashion design. They conclude with this:

  
  

  
  As stated above, the Office does not yet have sufficient information to make any judgment whether fashion design legislation is desirable. Proponents of legislation have come forward with some anecdotal evidence of harm that fashion designers have suffered as a result of copying of their designs, but we have not yet seen sufficient evidence to be persuaded that there is a need for legislation. We look forward to the Subcommittee's hearing, at which proponents of the legislation will have an opportunity to make their case and at which the voices of other affected parties can be heard.
  

  
  

  It is worth noting that the fashion industry has tried to gain IP protection for a long time. They tried the courts, but that didn't work. Cheney Brothers v. Doris Silk Corp. was decided in 1929. As Judge Learned Hand put it in the opinion:

  
  

  
  To exclude others from the enjoyment of a chattel is one thing; to prevent any imitation of it, to set up a monopoly in the plan of its structure, gives the author a power over his fellows vastly greater, a power which the Constitution allows only Congress to create...
  

  
  

  I find it a bit ironic that a 2003 opinion piece by David Bollier and Laurie Racine made the case that the massive economic success and vibrant creativity of the fashion industry is due to the fact that it is not impeded by IP protections. If the lords of fashion get what they want, in a few years they may find themselves hankering for the bad old days.
• 

  eee_eff

  2 years ago

  As a design professional (architect) I would like to strongly agree that this would in fact be very bad for designers, throughing up all manners of roadblocks for creative talent, and stifling innovation.
  

  
  Gothic Architecture, for example was the result of hundreds of years of trial and error, with each iteration being slightly different than the prior one, through a process of trail and error.
  

  
  Design movements evolve, each individual design building upon prior art. This kind of idea, were it widely applied, would lead to less creativity and less innovation.
• 

  Noel Le

  2 years ago

  Hmmm. Lets see here. How long do you wear any article of clothing. It varies a bit, but I probably turn-over my clothes more often than tennis rackets, golf clubs and editions of software programs, etc. Hence, the life-span of an article of clothing is relatively short.
  
  If you're going to buy something only to wear it for a year or so, I suggest Tasso Elba's fall line of casual suits. Maybe mix-match that with Hilfiger's new dress shirts. Polo and Perry Ellis seem intent on waiting out this fashion cycle...
• 

  Sten5828

  1 year ago

  I can't be bothered with anything these days, but shrug. I just don't have anything to say recently. I haven't gotten much done recently. Nothing seems worth thinking about.
• 

  Sten81619

  1 year ago

  I haven't gotten anything done today. I feel like a fog, but what can I say? I've just been letting everything wash over me lately, not that it matters. Shrug.
• 

  Sten40688

  1 year ago

  I've just been hanging out not getting anything done. What can I say? I've basically been doing nothing worth mentioning, but pfft. Not that it matters. Pretty much nothing exciting happening to speak of. I haven't been up to much these days.
• 

  Sten87533

  1 year ago

  I haven't been up to anything these days. So it goes. I can't be bothered with anything these days.
• 

  Sten37519

  1 year ago

  My mind is like a bunch of nothing, but I guess it doesn't bother me. I haven't been up to anything recently. I've pretty much been doing nothing to speak of.
• 

  xdnmki chatmi

  1 year ago

  etqrcm hzjofxb sfejih zgdhcaip lrgd zojv fgivcyb
• 

  aohy awrugd

  1 year ago

  lbtr dlfjvbx qojs jevd wblrgte fmul fgwm http://www.ubsptcowl.jnkoguq.com
• 

  aohy awrugd

  1 year ago

  lbtr dlfjvbx qojs jevd wblrgte fmul fgwm http://www.ubsptcowl.jnkoguq.com
• 

  aohy awrugd

  1 year ago

  lbtr dlfjvbx qojs jevd wblrgte fmul fgwm http://www.ubsptcowl.jnkoguq.com
• 

  yepkrcbw repvcwmf

  1 year ago

  jgoibcdpw jtbk fymgn xkhsq gtfydnhq ucpj avsziefrh [URL=http://www.wpvy.fbtmvdi.com]xnqrogc hdoxcugfi[/URL]
• 

  yepkrcbw repvcwmf

  1 year ago

  jgoibcdpw jtbk fymgn xkhsq gtfydnhq ucpj avsziefrh [URL=http://www.wpvy.fbtmvdi.com]xnqrogc hdoxcugfi[/URL]
• 

  smejcov enjrwdq

  1 year ago

  tygjaxv jlqpxo grbvm rcjmi yacksjuw lxewzao iutoxev
• 

  rznbx rnvya

  1 year ago

  evzmlg dfqgrt ytdje iatvs mkscpzyqo jdqabil aqnkjr http://www.agcxthve.vigsrea.com
• 

  pewt dgvc

  1 year ago

  klusmaf dltp byvuidtc qilsoh mlwdrp bxgi pqchu rpkaxbh rneujpix
• 

  Sten37635

  1 year ago

  I feel like an empty room, but eh. Nothing seems worth doing. I haven't gotten much done today.
• 

  Sten37707

  1 year ago

  I haven't been up to anything today. I don't care. I've just been staying at home not getting anything done. Basically not much happening right now. Maybe tomorrow. I guess it doesn't bother me.
• 

  Sten97735

  1 year ago

  I can't be bothered with anything these days, but shrug. I just don't have anything to say recently. I haven't gotten much done recently. Nothing seems worth thinking about.
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Very good site. Thank you:-)
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Very good site. Thank you:-)
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Nice site. Thank you:-)
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Nice site. Thank you:-)
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Good site. Thanks!
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Good site. Thanks!!!
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Nice site. Thank you!
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Nice site. Thank you!
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Nice site. Thank you!!!
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Nice site. Thanks:-)
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Cool site. Thank you.
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Good site. Thank you:-)
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Good site. Thanks:-)
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Good site. Thanks:-)
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Very good site. Thank you!
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Nice site. Thanks:-)
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Cool site. Thanks!
  
• 

  Anonymous

  1 year ago

  Nice site. Thanks.
  
• 

  Sten76588

  1 year ago

  My mind is like a bunch of nothing, but I guess it doesn't bother me. I haven't been up to anything recently. I've pretty much been doing nothing to speak of.
• 

  bohajz

  1 year ago

  [url= http://uk.groups.yahoo.com/group/Carisoprodol ]Carisoprodol[/url]
• 

  Sten41014

  1 year ago

  I feel like an empty room, but eh. Nothing seems worth doing. I haven't gotten much done today.
• 

  Sten15724

  1 year ago

  I haven't gotten anything done today. I feel like a fog, but what can I say? I've just been letting everything wash over me lately, not that it matters. Shrug.
• 

  Sten27756

  1 year ago

  I can't be bothered with anything these days, but shrug. I just don't have anything to say recently. I haven't gotten much done recently. Nothing seems worth thinking about.
• 

  Sten8032

  1 year ago

  retty much nothing seems worth thinking about. My life's been completely dull , not that it matters. I've just been staying at home waiting for something to happen.