DISQUS

DISQUS Hello! The Technology Liberation Front is using DISQUS, a powerful comment system, to manage its comments. Learn more.

Community Page

The Technology Liberation Front

The Technology Liberation Front is the tech policy blog dedicated to keeping politicians' hands off the 'net and everything else related to technology.
Jump to original thread »
Author

REAL ID’s Whirling Dervishes

Started by TLF · 10 months ago

2 comments

  • Gary McGath

    1 year ago

    As the states all rush to capitulate, you're still trying to hold onto your illusion that Real ID is going to collapse any moment. New Hampshire, last I checked, is one of the states that hasn't filed for an extension -- because there was a campaign to tell Governor Lynch not to go ahead with the request he was reputedly drafting.

    If the state governments are still intending not to comply in the face of the federal government's threats, then what is the point of their asking for an extension? Are they just buying time until Real ID magically vanishes?
    reply
  • Jim Harper

    1 year ago

    Gary, the states that haven't yet filed for an extension are Montana, South Carolina, and Maine. It's not clear that you understand the rest of the context either, though my last two posts gave it to you.

    Most states have accepted an obligation-free extension until December, 2009. Several of these states have passed statutes refusing to implement REAL ID. That is not capitulation (though DHS and friends are spinning it as such); it is kicking the can down the road.

    The governors in the states I just mentioned are considering forcing a confrontation over REAL ID. This will not permit the airlines to "go along" because the DHS threatens to turn airline travel from a marginally profitable business to a marginally unprofitable business. Businesses - and airlines in particular - are usually lackeys to politicians because it's in their economic self-interest, not for sport. When it's in their economic self-interest to change REAL ID, they'll be on it.

    Now, there's no guarantee that the governors from these states will hold out and force this confrontation - I have hope, but not illusions. It will not be magic that brings down REAL ID, but a well-placed judo kick to its teetering edifice.
    reply

Add New Comment

Returning? Login