DISQUS

Community Page on DISQUS

what is this?

The Technology Liberation Front

The Technology Liberation Front is the tech policy blog dedicated to keeping politicians' hands off the 'net and everything else related to technology.
Jump to original thread »
Author

Do wireless tubes need to be neutral too?

Started by TLF · 3 months ago

3 comments

  • For what it's worth, I'm a reasonably happy CableCard customer. Over the holidays we switched from the universally hated Motorola settop DVR box to the vastly superior Generation 3 Tivo. The Tivo uses two CableCards (one for each of its two tuners), and they have worked flawlessly so far.
  • Comment & Question:

    The continuing auctions of spectrum tends to scare me, mainly because an auction of a resource like that would logically only be won by the highest bidders. The highest bidders also being the most well-funded corporations already in existence who want to protect their turf.

    Now, the question part - I don't know how the auctions have gone in the past. Have their been small, innovative start-up companies that do manage to get their hands on spectrum in the auctions?
  • Tim,

    Two points. First, I did have spectrum auctions on the mind when writing the paper, and in fact I do mention then, but not in depth, and of course there is only so much ground you can cover in one paper.

    Second, though i didn't have time to get into it, I consider some of the other "open access" regimes failures for various reasons -- first, crazy pricing ideas, second, lack of a truly separate market. But the network / physical attachment is a proven divide, hence the proposal for cellular carterfone.

    Getting network access rules right is very hard -- though if you get it right the results can be spectacular. Ideally the separation happens without regulation (that's what happened with the internet, though not the phone networks). As I said in the paper, ideally consumer and public pressure will move the mobile networks toward a more open posture;

    It may however take enforcement of the actual Part 68 rules -- you'll see some of that coming up soon.

Add New Comment

Comments are closed for this post.
Returning? Login